• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Courtroom5

Be Your Own Lawyer

  • How It Works
  • Legal Tips
    • Access To Justice
    • Affirmative Defenses
    • Discovery
    • Dismissal
    • Legal Research
    • Litigation Strategy
    • Summary Judgment
  • Sign Up
  • Sign In

March 19, 2015 By Sonja Ebron 3 Comments

How To Answer A Complaint In Your Own Sweet Time

You’ve just been served with a lawsuit, and the law requires you to answer a complaint within a certain number of days or risk default. Or does it? Read the summons a little closer and you’ll find the language more precise. The law only requires you to respond to the complaint within three weeks (more or less, depending on your jurisdiction). Assuming you’ve been properly served, all you really need to do is acknowledge receipt. There are ways to comply that turn the tables on the plaintiff and let you control this phase of the case.

how to answer a complaintThe legal requirements for your response are defined in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, specifically F.R.C.P. 12(b), a variant of which exists in each state.

HOW TO PRESENT DEFENSES. Every defense to a claim for relief in any pleading must be asserted in the responsive pleading if one is required. But a party may assert the following defenses by motion:
(1) lack of subject-matter jurisdiction;
(2) lack of personal jurisdiction;
(3) improper venue;
(4) insufficient process;
(5) insufficient service of process;
(6) failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted; and
(7) failure to join a[n indispensable] party under Rule 19.
A motion asserting any of these defenses must be made before pleading if a responsive pleading is allowed. If a pleading sets out a claim for relief that does not require a responsive pleading, an opposing party may assert at trial any defense to that claim. No defense or objection is waived by joining it with one or more other defenses or objections in a responsive pleading or in a motion.

The part that lets you take control of the case is here: A motion asserting any of these defenses must be made before pleading if a responsive pleading is allowed. The “responsive pleading” is your answer, but defenses can be lodged — and must be ruled upon by the court — before you can be required to answer the complaint.

Why is this important? Plaintiffs have the upper hand when a complaint is filed because they or their attorneys have spent months studying the law, applying it to the facts of the case, and preparing their best arguments for why you owe them money. You probably didn’t even know it was coming. It’s unreasonable to expect you to learn the necessary law, recall or discover other facts and prepare a position statement that you’ll be stuck with throughout the case, all in 20 days or so. That goes triple for a pro se defendant. So you want to level the playing field. You want to take time to understand your legal situation before answering the complaint.

How do you do it? First, ask the court for more time to respond, say an extra 30 days. You’ll need a good reason — the search for a lawyer, for instance — but I’ve rarely seen a motion for extension of time denied. Second, prepare a motion to dismiss the complaint. Guided by Rule 12(b), check the jurisdiction, venue, service of process and indispensable parties that are absent from the case. If you find some defenses there, great. But focus like a laser on why the complaint fails to state a claim. Assuming everything the plaintiff has alleged is the absolute truth, is there something missing that lets you off the hook? Are there elements of the complaint that have not been asserted? Are there preconditions to filing suit that have not been asserted in the complaint? If so, the complaint is a failure and the court may dismiss it.

The beauty of a motion to dismiss is that you say nothing at all about your own position in the case. The only issue on a motion to dismiss is whether the complaint is good enough from a legal perspective to give a court the jurisdiction to hear it. But remember, the court will assume every factual allegation in the complaint is true, and no additional facts will be considered. No evidence at all will be considered; only the complaint and the law are relevant. It’s best to follow the rules of civil procedure in your state, so search your state’s rules for ‘defenses’ to find the analogy to F.R.C.P. 12(b).

Regardless of the merits, don’t count on the success of your dismissal motion. Most courts will err on the side of hearing a case. Even if you find some small defect that gets the complaint dismissed, the judge will likely do so “with leave to amend” or “without prejudice”, which allows the plaintiff to fix the complaint or refile it later. As a strategic matter, the purpose of your motion to dismiss is to give you time to do your research and prepare your answer. Getting the motion scheduled for hearing and ruled upon could take months. Use that time wisely.

More Like This:

  • Test Your Readiness For CourtTest Your Readiness For Court
  • If You're A Pro Se Plaintiff, This Manual Is For YouIf You're A Pro Se Plaintiff, This Manual Is For You
  • 11 Things To Consider When You Need To Sue11 Things To Consider When You Need To Sue
  • Best Blog Posts For Pro Se Litigants — The 2019 EditionBest Blog Posts For Pro Se Litigants — The 2019 Edition
  • Negotiating A Settlement You Can Live WithNegotiating A Settlement You Can Live With
  • What To Expect At Your First Court HearingWhat To Expect At Your First Court Hearing
  • Maximize Your Chances Of Getting Custody Of Minors After A DivorceMaximize Your Chances Of Getting Custody Of Minors…
  • 10 Reasons To Represent Yourself In Court10 Reasons To Represent Yourself In Court

Tagged With: complaint, defenses, response

About Sonja Ebron

Sonja Ebron is a co-founder at Courtroom5. She enjoys being underestimated in court and lives to catch a lawyer in a procedural error.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Eugene Smalls says

    August 22, 2018 at 8:05 pm

    Hello My sister: I like what you and your friends are doing. I am going to pass your company name to some friends I know. I am a well know Pro Se in the Court System for example the fight is not over. My wife and I gave Wells Fargo a run for their money they file a case against us started in 2009 and we made it to the US Supreme Court in 2017, but had the case reverse once at the appeals court level. Although Wells Fargo took out home in Alabama and we live in our other home here in Florida. We are getting ready to file a new complaint for different violation, which my understanding is for each violation the max per violation is up-to $1,000 and guess what we have a total of eighty different violation. Do the math our home was worth $110,000, but we had a balance of $60,000 left to pay we stand to win in a settlement at least have of $30,000 if not more.
    Not to brag by my Pro Se wining in Federal Court and Small claims started in the State of Hawaii. The Judge have titled me of being an expert on the Fair Credit Reporting Act I have sued all of the three credit reporting agency at lest twice and won each one. The judges wanted to write a letter for me to attend law school, but I never accepted the offer.
    I had sued the Government the VA in several claims and won. Our home here in Florida was in a foreclose suite and I went before the Bankruptcy Court in Delaware before the Chief Judge who is a women and one my case there. So I totally thank your for what you are doing to help people. I have help people in different lawsuit as a ghost writer and they won their case over 20 years until recently I stop helping it was just to much to keep up with in all the different law in fact I started out in self-study in Discrimination Title 7 for seven years and was on the Board with NAACP in Hawaii.
    My hardest case is Federal Workers Comp, but over 20 years of fighting I learned how to win them with their own law.
    All of my filing and different case and Motion I have on many flash drive in a safe over the years.
    To be honest the best part of it all when my wife and I walk into a Court room, we do not walk in alone, we have Jesus by our side and he have never let us down. I will say that my track records is over thirty wins and four lost.
    I will be praying for you and your partner to keep up the good work.
    God bless you.

    Reply
    • Sonja Ebron says

      August 23, 2018 at 7:29 pm

      Thanks for sharing your story, Eugene, and for your kind words. Thanks also for your efforts to help people over the years. Successes like yours are a model of what we aim for at Courtroom5. Please stay in touch.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Get Our Free 5-Day Course to Your Inbox

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We hate spam too. We'll never share your email.

Popular Articles

  • 31 affirmative defenses 31 Affirmative Defenses And How To Assert Them
  • biggest mistakes pro se litigants make 6 Of The Biggest Mistakes Pro Se Litigants Make
  • How to Write a Motion How To Write A Motion--A Guide And Sample Motions For Pro Se Litigants

Popular Tags

access to justice affirmative defenses answer appeal bias Brian Vukadinovich case analysis Case Manager civil legal aid complaint constitution court costs court reporter Courtroom5 criminal discovery elements of a claim eviction evidence hearing how to win in court I Am Not A Lawyer judicial bias jurisdiction Lawyers We Love legal analysis legal argument Legal Bits legal research litigation litigation strategy motion for summary judgment motion to dismiss podcast pro se litigants pro se litigation Richard Zorza rules of civil procedure self-representation self represented litigant settlement Sonja Ebron summary judgment trial unbundled legal services
Follow @Courtroom5Legal
Courtroom5
Courtroom5 @Courtroom5Legal
7 hours ago
With the world, we mourn the passing of Hank Aaron - Baseball Hall of Famer, civil rights icon, philanthropist, Presidential Medal of Freedom holder, and strong advocate for #accesstojustice. https://t.co/9bleQMpZwu
View on Twitter
0
2
Courtroom5
Courtroom5 @Courtroom5Legal
2 days ago
“What just is, isn’t always Jus-tice.” Amanda Gorman, Biden/Harris Inaugural Poet, January 20, 2021 https://t.co/PGkrc4uQ49
View on Twitter
0
2
Courtroom5
Courtroom5 @Courtroom5Legal
4 days ago
Justice is the antidote to chaos. Happy Martin Luther King Day 2021. #accesstojustice https://t.co/Bspn62idc5
View on Twitter
0
1
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

© 2021 Courtroom5 | A Techstars Company · My Account
No legal advice offered · No substitute for a lawyer

We use cookies to ensure the best experience on our website. If you continue to browse Courtroom5, we assume this is okay for you.OK